Is Growing Pumpkins Worth It? What Two Very Different Seasons Taught Me

Helping you celebrate the magic of every season!

Every fall at Two Sisters Flower Farm, we trade the armloads of fresh flowers we grow all summer for wagonloads of pumpkins.

And while I’ve come to love this part of our growing season, I’ll admit there have been years when I’ve questioned whether growing pumpkins is worth all the effort.

We plant approximately four to five acres of pumpkins each year, which means there’s a considerable amount of work involved long before the first customer ever pulls into our driveway.

There’s the expense of seed, preparing the fields, managing weeds, and hoping the weather cooperates. And then, of course, there’s the harvest. Pumpkins are heavy, bulky, and require a tremendous amount of handling before they ever make it onto a display at the farm stand.

Some years, all that work pays off beautifully. Other years, it’s a little harder to see the return.

And 2025 was one of those years for us.

We struggled with difficult growing conditions, including drought that affected our harvest, and ultimately had to purchase additional pumpkins just to keep the stand stocked.

By the time October came to an end, I was tired. We’d worked incredibly hard, and I couldn’t help wondering whether the return justified everything we’d put into the season.

So when it came time to plant pumpkins again in 2026, I think I approached the season with a little more caution.

We planted our fields, tended the crop, and prepared for another fall, just as we’d done in previous years. But after the challenges of the year before, I wasn’t making too many assumptions about how things would turn out.

Fortunately, this growing season was much kinder to us. And by the end of this past October, we experienced one of our most successful fall seasons to date.

But as I’ve spent time reflecting on what made these two seasons so different, I’ve realized that some of the most valuable lessons had surprisingly little to do with growing pumpkins.

They had more to do with how we approached the business of selling them, the opportunities we chose to pursue, and what I’ve come to understand about running a farm after nearly a decade of experience.

And I think those lessons are worth sharing, especially for anyone who’s ever questioned whether all the time, money, and effort they’re putting into their business is actually paying off.

So, What Changed?

One of the things I’ve found most interesting about looking back on these two seasons is just how similar our approach to growing pumpkins actually was.

We planted approximately the same acreage, invested in much of the same equipment and supplies, and operated our fall farm stand much as we had in previous years.

We hadn’t made some dramatic change to our production methods or significantly increased the number of pumpkins we were growing. We also hadn’t decided to scale back production in an effort to reduce expenses.

Of course, the weather played a significant role. We had a much better growing season this year, which meant a healthier crop and more pumpkins available to sell. And the unusually warm, dry fall certainly worked in our favor when it came to getting customers out to the farm stand.

I don’t want to overlook either of those things, because they made an enormous difference.

But as I’ve reflected on the season, I’ve also realized that some of the most meaningful changes happened in how we approached the business itself.

And I think the first of those changes was where we chose to focus our attention.

Making the Most of the Opportunity in Front of Us

I’ll admit that after such a difficult season last year, I felt a sense of relief when customers began visiting the stand during those first couple of weeks in September.

Our regular customers were returning, we were seeing plenty of new faces, and it was clear that we were off to a strong start.

I still wasn’t sure how the rest of the season would unfold, but as September progressed and sales continued to build, I found myself becoming increasingly focused on what was happening right here at the farm.

In previous years, our attention during the fall often got diverted to other things. We hosted U-Dig dahlia events during the fall. We’d taken products to outside vendor markets and had various other activities happening alongside our regular farm stand operation.

This year, however, we didn’t.

It wasn’t necessarily a decision I’d made months in advance. As the season gained momentum, I simply became less interested in dividing my attention between additional offerings when there was already so much happening at the farm stand.

We had pumpkins in the field, mums ready to sell, and customers coming to purchase them. And I was beginning to recognize how much opportunity there was in giving our existing fall operation my full attention.

I think that was a little different from how I might have approached things earlier in my business journey.

When you’re building a business, it’s easy to see every new market, event, or product as another opportunity to generate revenue. I’ve certainly been guilty of that over the years.

I’d come across an interesting idea or see something another farm was doing and immediately begin wondering whether we should be doing something similar.

Over time, though, I’ve become more selective about those decisions. And I think much of that comes back to a business lesson I’ve understood for years, even if I haven’t always been particularly good at putting it into practice.

Know the value you provide, and know who you’re providing it for.

This lesson really hit home for me earlier this fall when I came across a social media post from a local influencer sharing her family’s visit to a pumpkin patch.

She was walking through their day, sharing the activities they’d enjoyed, the food they’d purchased, and how much they’d spent along the way.

The post initially caught my attention because the pumpkin patch was relatively close to us. But what stayed with me was that after spending a considerable amount of money on their visit, the family had gone home without purchasing a single pumpkin.

And I remember thinking how interesting that was.

This family had visited a pumpkin farm, spent money, enjoyed themselves, and left without buying the very product I’d always associated with a pumpkin patch.

But of course, that wasn’t really what they’d gone there to purchase. They’d gone for the experience.

And seeing that distinction made me think about our own farm stand and the customers we serve.

At Two Sisters, people primarily visit to purchase pumpkins, mums, and other seasonal products for their homes. We love welcoming families, and there’s something especially enjoyable about watching children choose their pumpkins, but our business is built around a different kind of customer experience.

Neither approach is inherently better. They’re simply serving different needs.

And while I can appreciate what other farms have created, I don’t necessarily need to recreate those experiences here.

There’s still plenty of opportunity to grow our business by becoming better at serving the customers who already come to us.

Being Prepared for the Customers Who Come

The other significant change was how we approached keeping the farm stand stocked throughout the season.

And interestingly enough, this was a lesson I’d first started learning years earlier when we began opening our winter shop for Christmas.

At the time, we were making and selling wreaths, porch pots, and other holiday greenery. Because nearly everything had to be made by hand, I was hesitant to prepare too much inventory before I knew how many customers to expect.

Every wreath and porch pot represented an investment of materials and labor, and I didn’t want to spend time making products that might never sell.

So while we always had inventory prepared for our customers, I tended to err on the side of caution, making what I felt confident we could sell rather than preparing for the possibility of greater demand.

Of course, the challenge with that approach is that customers can’t purchase something that isn’t available.

It seems obvious now, but I think it took me several seasons to fully appreciate how much preparation matters in retail, particularly when you have a relatively short window to generate sales.

And this fall, I found myself returning to that lesson, although in a slightly different way.

Now, we’ve always been diligent about keeping our farm stand stocked, but in previous years, our harvesting schedule was often dictated by how much inventory remained at the stand. We’d look at what was available, determine what needed replenishing, and decide whether it was time to head back into the field.

This year, I approached things a little differently.

We were harvesting pumpkins nearly every day throughout our fall season, right up through Halloween. Unless the weather prevented us, picking pumpkins became part of our regular routine, regardless of how full the displays happened to be that morning.

And honestly, there were times when we’d harvested more pumpkins than we had room for at the stand. Rather than slowing down, I found myself making room for them, finding additional surfaces and creating new displays to accommodate the inventory.

It might seem like a relatively small operational change, but I think it reflected a much bigger shift in how I was approaching the season.

In previous years, I often allowed the amount of inventory remaining at the stand to determine how much we needed to harvest. This year, I was thinking more about how much inventory we wanted to have available for the customers we hoped would continue coming.

I wasn’t taking the demand for granted. I was simply making a more intentional effort to stay ahead of it.

And I think there’s a larger business lesson in that. We can spend so much time hoping for more customers and working to grow our businesses, but we also have to be prepared to serve those customers when they arrive.

After all, there’s little sense in wanting more customers if we haven’t made sure there’s something available for them to purchase.

There were plenty of days when I was tired of harvesting pumpkins, particularly as we approached the end of October. But even during those final days, we continued picking because customers were still purchasing them.

Looking back, I think that willingness to stay ahead of the demand, even when the work was tiring, was an important part of what made this season successful.

What This Season Taught Me About Growing a Business

By the time we closed the stand for the season, we’d experienced one of our strongest falls to date.

We were working with much of the same infrastructure, similar quantities of pumpkins and mums, and the same relatively short selling season.

But we’d approached the season with a little more intention about where we invested our attention and how we managed the demand we were experiencing.

And as I’ve spent time reflecting on the season, I’ve realized how closely that experience relates to some of the larger questions I’ve been considering about the future of our business.

For years, I’ve been excited by the possibilities of what Two Sisters Flower Farm could become. There are still plenty of ideas I’d love to explore, and I don’t expect that excitement to disappear anytime soon.

But I’ve also become increasingly aware of how easy it is to keep adding new things without ever fully developing the ones you’ve already started.

Every additional offering requires some combination of money, time, infrastructure, and attention. Even when an idea has the potential to generate revenue, it also creates another part of the business that needs to be managed.

And while I still believe there’s room for us to expand in the future, I’ve become more interested in understanding how much potential exists within the things we’ve already built.

Our fall farm stand is a good example.

We’ve invested years into growing pumpkins and mums, developing our customer base, and creating a seasonal retail operation. Yet this fall made me realize how much opportunity still exists to improve the way we operate and make better use of those investments.

Rather than continually looking for additional revenue streams, I’m becoming more interested in increasing the capacity of the business we already have.

There’s still plenty of work involved in that approach, and in some ways, I think it requires more discipline than pursuing something new. Improving an existing operation isn’t always particularly exciting, especially when the work involves doing many of the same things you’ve done for years.

But I’ve come to appreciate how much value can be created by giving those things the attention they deserve.

So, Is Growing Pumpkins Worth It?

After two very different seasons, I still believe growing pumpkins is worthwhile for our business.

They’re a considerable investment, and there’s no getting around the amount of land, equipment, labor, and uncertainty involved. I certainly wouldn’t suggest that every flower farmer should plant five acres of pumpkins simply because we’ve had success with them.

But for Two Sisters, pumpkins have become an important part of our seasonal farm stand. They complement the mums and other fall products we grow, and they allow us to continue serving customers long after our summer flowers have finished.

This season also gave me a better understanding of how much opportunity exists within that relatively simple business model.

We didn’t need to grow significantly more pumpkins or create additional reasons for customers to visit the farm. We needed to make better use of the pumpkins we’d already grown and the customer demand we were fortunate enough to experience.

I think that realization has been particularly meaningful after nearly a decade of building this business.

For a long time, growth seemed closely connected to the idea of adding something new. Another product, another experience, another way to generate revenue.

And while those opportunities can certainly have their place, I’m beginning to recognize that there’s another way to grow.

One that involves taking a closer look at what you’ve already created, understanding where there’s still room for improvement, and being willing to invest the time and effort required to develop it further.

Looking back, I’m grateful for the favorable growing conditions, the customers who supported us, and the family and helpers who made such a busy season possible.

I’m also grateful for the perspective that came from experiencing two very different years.

The challenges of 2025 reminded me how much uncertainty comes with running a seasonal farm business. The success of this year reminded me how much opportunity can exist within the business we’ve already built.

As I think about where I want to take Two Sisters Flower Farm in the years ahead, I find myself increasingly interested in growing the capacity of what we already do before adding to its complexity.

There’s still plenty I’d like to accomplish, but I don’t necessarily think it requires us to keep adding more.

At least for now, I’m interested in seeing just how much further we can take what we’ve already started.

Picture of Britney Zondlak

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hey there, I'm Britney!

A dairy farmer turned flower farmer growing + selling specialty cut flowers in West Michigan! I think flowers are the best way to savor the magic that comes with every season- that’s why at Two Sisters Flower Farm we grow everything from daffodils in the spring to pumpkins + dahlias in the fall!

Popular Posts:

Resources to Help You Grow Flowers:

Resources to Help You Profit Even in the Off-Season:

Step Into a Flower-Filled Life

Get instant access to a free, three-part video experience exploring why so many are turning to flowers — and how you can start, right where you are.

Updating…
  • No products in the cart.